F&M Baseball All-Conference Selections

Year First Team Second Team Honorable Mention Rookie of the Year 
1968 Kim Frankford, George Dreisbach      
1971 Robert Hiltner, Jack Brunner, James Teagle, Jay Baumgardner      
1972 Robert Hiltner, Ed Bosch    Keith Dukes, Jay Teagle, Larry Shadek, Bob Olender, Jack Brunner  
1973 Clint Lynch, Ed Bosch, Bob Olender (MVP MAC South)    Jay Teagle  
1974 Keith Dukes, Clint Lynch, Jeff Rineer      
1976   Larry Fine, Alex Kolobielski    
1978   Tom Christman, Tom Bachman, Jeff Wagner    
1979   David Heiges    
1980 Al Taylor  Brian Fatse, David Heiges, Rick Herr, Jeff Wagner    
1982 Dennis Dowd, Al Taylor      
1984   Doug Fulmer    
1985 Chris Hackman      
1987 Dale Amos      
1988 Andy Zuch      
1990   Paul Olivett, Chris Rebman, Andy Zuch, Scott Focht, Jake Kohlen    
1991 Jake Kohlen, Chris Rebman      
1992 Jake Kolen      
1994 Rod Mummaw Matt Pisano Darren Maccanico  
1995 Bill Boyle, Eric Lanks, Tim Sheridan, Darren Maccanico Jesse Fluck Brad Zerbe, Jamie McCall  
1996 Tim Sheridan Greg Shambaugh, Beau Eckert     
1997 Jamie McCall, Beau Eckert      
1998 Greg Shambaugh      
1999 Greg Shambaugh   Dustin Derr, Josh Tartaglione  
2000   Sean Calhoon    
2001   Chris Zoeller, Don Klein    
2002 Andy Meyers, Chris Zoeller, Sal Monaco John Walsh, Dustin Derr Dan Webber, Gordie Eck  
2003   Chris Smith    
2004 Dan Weber, Gary Kruger, Scott Haft Dan Hanecak Rob Georgiou  
2005 Ted Serro, Corey Caruthers Stephen Frederick, Dan Hanecak Jeremy Knox, Gary Kruger  
2006 Ted Serro, Gary Kruger, Eric Milavsky Jeremy Knox, Stephen Frederick, Rob Stern, Corey Caruthers    
2007 Dan Tischler Brad Andres, Pat O'Reilly, Mark Minutaglio, Rich Gallugi Jeff Rowand, Gordon Pellegrini  
2008 Jason Anderson, Shea Moriarty Andrew Hanson, Matt Kalos, Patrick O'Reilly    
2009 Andrew Hanson, Nick Markel, Matt Will Bill Murray Nick Rolnick, Jay Anderson  
2010 Matt Will Bill Murray J.T. Triantos  
2011 J.T. Triantos, Will Benenson Mike Duranti, Eric Bornstein Matt Will  
2012     J.T. Triantos  
2013 Alex Vescera, Aaron Gillette Brendan DeMond   Matt Mezansky
2014   Rob Anderson    
2015 Dan Marano, Andrew Mascis Alex Guerra, David Iacobucci, Luke Seib Christopher Vincent Dan Marano
2016 Andrew Mascis, David Iacobucci Mike Androconis    
2017   Mike Androconis, David Iacobucci, Christopher Vincent, Reed Williams Danny Blugis